If You Love Them, You'll Caretake Them – True or False? 🤨


Notes From a Relationship Coach
(Big ideas in a small email)

“Rescuing or caretaking is not an act of love.”

–Melody Beattie, Codependent No More

One of my very best friends (I literally cry when I think about how much I love this man) got injured and lost his job recently. His wife texted me the news and added “He could really use you right now.” I was like, “Say no more, I’m looking at flights.”

Not gonna lie, I started thinking of all the ways I could help and therapy and coach and advise. I thought, “I don’t have any mouths to feed, I can just give them a buncha money.”

But when I arrived, I remembered that he is one of the most resilient and capable human beings I know. And he didn’t need someone to medevac him out of his life. He just needed a friend to BE WITH HIM in the middle of it. To be reminded that he’s ok and loved no matter what.

People don’t wanna be saved, they wanna be seen.

“Caretaking,” as Melody Beattie uses it, is compulsive helping, fixing, saving, enabling, or over-functioning that may relieve the helper’s anxiety but diminishes the other person’s agency.

Caring says, “I see you. I love you. I’m available. How can I support you without unnecessarily inserting myself into your life and robbing you of any power or opportunities?”

Caretaking says, “I can’t tolerate your discomfort, your consequences, your process, or my own anxiety, so I’m gonna manage this for you.” It’s actually kinda selfish and potentially shaming, alienating, or crippling.

I suspect parenting is theeee most difficult place to make this distinction. But that’s a whole nother email I’m not prepared to write, haha.

•Who are the people you care about the most?
•Can you tell when you’re caring vs caretaking with them?
•What might you do differently in those relationships?

With Love,

*This email contains Amazon affiliate links to the books mentioned.


If an amazing friend forwarded you this email, you can subscribe here.
If YOU are an amazing friend, go on and forward this thang.

Adam Murauskas

Help me help you. Sign up to receive free relationship coaching content.

Read more from Adam Murauskas
Cover of Esther Perel's book Mating In Captivity

Notes From a Relationship Coach(Big ideas in a small email) “What is true intimacy but an ability to hold onto myself while I’m with you?” –Esther Perel, Mating in Captivity I grew up thinking I needed to suffer, sacrifice, and shrink to earn a seat in my family – like that was literally the price of connection. I figured grin and bear it was just what I had to do to “make it work.” And, unfortunately, I carried that idea into all my adult relationships. With decades of personal and...

Cover of Martin Buber's book, I and Thou

Notes From a Relationship Coach(Big ideas in a small email) “All real living is meeting.” –Martin Buber, I and Thou Intimacy is rooted in authenticity and freedom – two people willingly giving of themselves from mutual desire and genuine interest. The moment we begin to act from obligation, fear, shame, or ulterior motives, connection turns into performance. And something magical is lost. But wait… I’m doing the same things I was doing when we fell in love. Isn’t this the formula? No. There...

Selfie of me on the beach holding a sand dollar

Notes From a Relationship Coach(Big ideas in a small email) “Don’t pay for anyone to be where you wish they were.” –Adam Murauskas This started as advice to someone who was overspending on flights and trips in order to be with someone who couldn’t afford that lifestyle (and it wasn’t really working out for anyone involved). But I quickly saw the deeper truth beyond finance: If you are chronically accommodating, suffering in silence, walking on eggshells, bending over backwards, going wantless...